You were told a VA cash-out refinance can go up to 100% of your home's value. Then a quote came back capped at 90%. Both statements can be true at once, and the gap between them has nothing to do with you, your credit, or your service.
The 100% figure is the VA's rule. The 90% figure is usually a business decision made after the VA's rule, and it traces back to how VA loans are sold to investors once they close. Smart people run into this every week. The reason is buried in a 2019 securities memo most homeowners never hear about.
Below: what the VA actually allows, where the 90% cap comes from, what that cap costs a household in real dollars, and how to read a VA cash-out refinance offer so you know which number you're looking at.
What the VA allows on a cash-out refinance
The rule lives in federal regulation, at 38 CFR 36.4306. It says the new loan amount must not exceed 100% of the home's reasonable value, as set by the VA appraisal.
Three details in that same rule matter here.
- The VA funding fee can be rolled into the loan, but only up to the 100% line. Any part of the fee that would push the loan past 100% of value has to be paid in cash at closing.
- The new loan must pass a net tangible benefit test. It has to meet at least one of eight listed benefits, such as a lower payment, a shorter term, more monthly residual income, or getting rid of monthly mortgage insurance.
- One of those eight benefits is simply a loan amount at or below 90% of the home's value. Keep that in mind. It is one of the reasons 90% shows up so often.
So from the VA's side, a VA cash-out refinance can reach 100% of appraised value. That ceiling is earned through your service. It doesn't shrink because the loan is a refinance. We walk through the full LTV math in how much you can borrow on a VA cash-out.
Where the 90% cap comes from
Most VA loans don't stay with the company that closes them. They are bundled into mortgage-backed securities that carry a Ginnie Mae guarantee and are sold to investors. That's how the money gets recycled into new loans.
In 2019, Ginnie Mae changed which VA cash-out loans could go into its standard pools. According to the HUD announcement of the change, VA cash-out refinance loans with a loan-to-value above 90% became ineligible for the two standard pool types, effective with securities guaranteed on or after November 1, 2019. Those loans can still be pooled, but only in a separate custom pool.
Ginnie Mae gave a plain reason: cash-out refinances tend to be paid off faster than other loans, and putting the high-LTV ones in their own pools gives investors a clearer view when they price the securities.
Notice what did not change. The VA's 100% rule stayed exactly where it was. The change was about how the loans are packaged and sold after closing.
Why that leads to a cap
A loan that has to go into a custom pool is more work to sell, and investors may price it differently. Some lenders looked at that and decided to stop at 90%. That internal limit, set on top of the VA's own rule, is called an overlay.
An overlay is legal. The company is allowed to lend less than the VA permits. But it means two quotes for the same veteran, on the same house, can be built on two different ceilings, and the borrower is rarely told why.
The other reason you see 90%
Remember the net tangible benefit test. A loan at or below 90% of value passes one of the eight tests automatically. Above 90%, the loan has to qualify on another benefit, like a lower payment or more residual income, and that has to be documented. That takes more paperwork. It is still very doable. For a household paying off high-interest cards with the cash, more monthly residual income is often the clearest benefit of all.
What a 90% cap costs in real dollars
Here is an illustration with round numbers. Say your home appraises at $400,000.
- At 90% LTV, the largest loan is $360,000.
- At 100% LTV, the largest loan is $400,000.
That's a $40,000 difference in what the refinance can do. If you owe $300,000 on the mortgage, the 90% ceiling leaves about $60,000 for closing costs, the funding fee and debt payoff. The 100% ceiling leaves about $100,000.
For a household carrying $80,000 across credit cards and a car loan, that gap is the difference between a plan that clears every balance and one that leaves some of the most expensive debt in place. The leftover cards keep charging card-level interest, often far above the mortgage rate. That leftover debt is what drags the household's real rate up.
The full picture, not the mortgage rate
This is where the conversation usually goes wrong. People compare two offers on the mortgage rate alone and pick the lower one. But if the lower-rate offer is capped at 90% and leaves $20,000 on cards, the household may pay more interest in total than it would under a slightly higher-rate loan that pays everything off.
What matters is your blended rate, sometimes called a Household Rate: the weighted average interest across the mortgage and every debt you carry. A good mortgage rate sitting next to a pile of card balances is a low number hiding a high one.
To compare two VA cash-out refinance offers fairly, line up:
- the loan amount and the LTV each offer is built on
- which debts each one pays off, and which it leaves open
- total closing costs and the funding fee, and whether any of the fee must be paid in cash
- the new monthly payment for the mortgage plus every remaining debt
- how many years until the household is debt-free, with the monthly saving applied to the loan
When borrowing less than 100% is the right call
Going to 100% is a tool. It fits some households better than others.
Borrowing to the line makes the most sense when the extra room clears high-interest debt that would otherwise stay open for years. It makes less sense if the cash would go to spending you'd rather not finance over decades.
The VA also requires the lender to show you, in writing, how much home equity the refinance removes and to explain that this may affect your ability to sell later. Under 38 CFR 36.4306, you get that comparison twice: within 3 business days of your application and again at closing. Read it. It's there to protect you.
If you expect to sell within a few years, keeping more equity in the home may matter more than paying off every last balance. A specialist can model both versions so you see the trade with your own numbers.
How GoodLoan approaches the 90% question
We build VA cash-out refinance plans up to the VA's own 100% ceiling when the appraisal, your entitlement and the VA's benefit tests support it. We don't stop at 90% because of how a loan gets packaged later.
Inside that ceiling, the plan pays off the home's liens first, then the debts that free up the most monthly payment for each dollar paid off. If the funding fee would push the loan past 100% of value, that part of the fee comes out of the cash at closing, as the VA requires, instead of leaving a debt unpaid.
Every plan shows the full picture side by side: today's payments and blended rate, the plan's payments and blended rate, closing costs, and the date the household is debt-free with the monthly saving applied to the loan. Some households prefer a smaller loan, and the plan can show that version as well. Final terms depend on the appraisal, underwriting and VA eligibility, so nothing here is a promise of approval or of a specific loan amount.
We are licensed through the NMLS and approved to make VA loans.
Next step
If you've been quoted a 90% cap and want to know what your full plan looks like at the VA's own limit, talk with a GoodLoan specialist. Call, text or chat (866) 599-0088, 8am to 8pm Eastern.
Frequently asked questions
Does the VA cap cash-out refinances at 90%?
No. The VA's rule in 38 CFR 36.4306 allows a VA cash-out refinance up to 100% of the home's reasonable value, as set by the VA appraisal. A 90% limit is usually an internal choice by the company making the loan, not a VA requirement.
Why did 90% become common after 2019?
Ginnie Mae made VA cash-out loans above 90% LTV ineligible for its standard securities pools, effective November 1, 2019. Those loans can only go into custom pools. Some lenders responded by stopping at 90% instead of handling the custom-pool path.
Can the VA funding fee push my loan over 100%?
No. The fee can be financed only up to 100% of the home's value. Any part that would go over must be paid at closing, which usually means it comes out of your cash back. The VA funding fee page lists the rates: 2.15% for a first-use cash-out refinance and 3.3% after first use, under the table effective April 7, 2023.
Am I exempt from the funding fee?
You may be. Veterans who receive VA compensation for a service-connected disability are exempt, along with several other groups listed on the VA funding fee page, including some surviving spouses and Purple Heart recipients on active duty. An exemption leaves more room under the 100% line for paying off debt.
Is a loan above 90% harder to qualify for?
It has to pass the VA's net tangible benefit test on something other than the 90% item, such as a lower payment or more monthly residual income. For many households using cash-out to pay off card debt, more residual income is the benefit that applies. Credit, income and the appraisal still need to meet VA and underwriting standards.
Should I always borrow the full 100%?
Not always. It's worth it when the extra room clears expensive debt you'd otherwise carry for years. If you plan to sell soon or don't need the cash, a smaller loan keeps more equity in the home. A specialist can show both versions side by side.